Too soon for a truce? Israel downplays push for ceasefire with Hezbollah

Alessandro XENOS | Rebecca GNIGNATI | François PICARD | Gil MIHAELY | Rima TARABAY | Abram PALEY | Filippo DIONIGI

Edité par France 24 - 2024

As Israeli jets continue to pound Lebanon, as top brass talk up the potential for a ground invasion, Hezbollah and its main backer Iran are more circumspect: they are still reeling from last week's exploding electronic devices and the killing of three of the militant group's top commanders. They would gladly consider an all-in-one US plan to wind up fighting both in Gaza and on Lebanon's border. 

The question remains: what are Israel's goals going forward? Has it weakened Hezbollah enough? Has it restored an aura of regional might that first teetered with its inconclusive 2006 war with Hezbollah and then shattered last October 7 when Hamas attacked from Gaza? Can a prime minister who probably faces an inquiry over Gaza when the guns go silent keep up a perpetual state of war? And is Lebanon doomed to forever remain a battleground for all the region's proxy wars?

Produced by Alessandro Xenos, Rebecca Gnignati and Mélissa Kalaydjian.

Note
  • Ceasefire or all-out war? While Israel's prime minister headed to UN Week in New York, his office stated that Binyamin Netanyahu had not even started considering a Franco-American plan for a 21-day truce with Hezbollah. Word of the plan was greeted with immediate pushback from hawks within Netanyahu's right-wing cabinet.

Langue
anglais
Date de publication
26/09/2024
Collection
The Debate
Contributeurs
Gil MIHAELY Editor-in-Chief, Causeur
Rima TARABAY Former Advisor to Rafik Hariri (1992-2005)
Abram PALEY United States' Deputy Special Envoy for Iran
Filippo DIONIGI Senior Lecturer of Politics and International Relations at the University of Bristol

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Tanks in Rafah: Will Israeli operation scuttle or unblock truce talks? | François PICARD

Tanks in Rafah: Will Israeli operation scuttl...

| François PICARD | 2024

It’s been an up-and-down 24 hours for Gaza residents, who initially thought a first ceasefire since November was finally at hand, thus sparing Rafah. But perhaps it's when it all comes to a head that the real bargaining begins.&nb...

PM non grata? Israel blasts ICC bid to charge both Netanyahu and Hamas | François PICARD

PM non grata? Israel blasts ICC bid to charge...

| François PICARD | 2024

We ask about the alleged war crimes, the measure of the request and the sharp reactions. The US president has branded "outrageous" the accusations against Prime Minister Netanyahu and his defence chief Yoav Gallant, with the likes...

After Sinwar's death: Why is Israel ramping up strikes in Lebanon and Gaza? | François PICARD

After Sinwar's death: Why is Israel ramping u...

| François PICARD | 2024

We ask if we are witnessing the storm before the calm, or if there is no plan to de-escalate.With the US Secretary of State following Hochstein, Israel is mindful of growing pressure from its allies and is organising press tours f...

After Israel-Hezbollah ceasefire: Too soon to call it de-escalation? | François PICARD

After Israel-Hezbollah ceasefire: Too soon to...

| François PICARD | 2024

At the centre of it all is the ultimate political survivor: Binyamin Netanyahu. But does Israel's longest-serving prime minister still need a forever war in Gaza to stave off inquiries into the failures of October 7 and his own co...

How serious is he? Trump's plan for Gaza | François PICARD

How serious is he? Trump's plan for Gaza

| François PICARD

How does one rebuild Gaza after destruction on a biblical scale? In the aftermath of past wars, Gulf states footed much of the bill. The money went to housing, but was also sometimes diverted by Hamas. We gauge regional react...

Only way to defend Kharkiv? France eases conditions for its weapons to target Russia | François PICARD

Only way to defend Kharkiv? France eases cond...

| François PICARD | 2024

It's in the name of Kharkiv that French President Emmanuel Macron, on a state visit to Germany – with Chancellor Olaf Scholz nodding in agreement – said he would allow French missiles supplied to Ukraine to, as he put it, "ne...

What if the ANC does not win? South Africa's most uncertain elections since 1994 | François PICARD

What if the ANC does not win? South Africa's ...

| François PICARD | 2024

We ask about a sluggish economy, huge inequality, corruption and whether this time incumbent fatigue will finally catch up with the African National Congress. How will those born after the fall of apartheid vote? How do they see a...

Macron in New Caledonia: Will surprise visit quell tensions on French Pacific island? | François PICARD

Macron in New Caledonia: Will surprise visit ...

| François PICARD | 2024

The last time New Caledonia witnessed this kind of eruption was the 1980s. Then, too, it was electoral reform that lit the spark. It ended with a carefully-worded deal that granted a special status to an overseas collectivity whic...

Uncertainty in Iran: What next after president's death in helicopter crash? | François PICARD

Uncertainty in Iran: What next after presiden...

| François PICARD | 2024

We ask about the crash and the challenges ahead for Iran.Then there are the country's 88 million citizens. Will they get involved? Since Raisi was elected in 2021, the regime has stared down the massive "women, life, freedom" prot...