PM non grata? Israel blasts ICC bid to charge both Netanyahu and Hamas

François PICARD | Alessandro XENOS | Rebecca GNIGNATI | Imen MELLAZ | Nomi BAR-YAACOV | Gil MIHAELY | William JULIÉ | Johann SOUFI

Edité par France 24 - 2024

We ask about the alleged war crimes, the measure of the request and the sharp reactions. The US president has branded "outrageous" the accusations against Prime Minister Netanyahu and his defence chief Yoav Gallant, with the likes of the UK, Italy and Germany bemoaning "the inaccurate impression of an equivalence" between both sides.

France is among those that leave the matter to the judges of the ICC, an international court with jurisdiction in 124 nations. The ICC has indicted sitting leaders before, but never a democratically elected one.

What impact will the move have on Israel's reputation and on its politics? And will these charges alleviate the suffering in Gaza?

Produced by Alessandro Xenos, Rebecca Gnignati and Imen Mellaz.

Note
  • Is it about justice or politics? In the same breath, the chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court requested arrest warrants against both Israel's Binyamin Netanyahu and Hamas's Yahya Sinwar.

Langue
anglais
Date de publication
21/05/2024
Collection
The Debate
Contributeurs
Nomi BAR-YAACOV Associate Fellow, International Security Programme, Chatham House
Gil MIHAELY Editor-in-Chief, Causeur
William JULIÉ Criminal Defence and Human Rights Lawyer
Johann SOUFI International Lawyer, Former Head of Legal, UNRWA in Gaza

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

After Israel-Hezbollah ceasefire: Too soon to...

| François PICARD | 2024

At the centre of it all is the ultimate political survivor: Binyamin Netanyahu. But does Israel's longest-serving prime minister still need a forever war in Gaza to stave off inquiries into the failures of October 7 and his own co...

Tanks in Rafah: Will Israeli operation scuttl...

| François PICARD | 2024

It’s been an up-and-down 24 hours for Gaza residents, who initially thought a first ceasefire since November was finally at hand, thus sparing Rafah. But perhaps it's when it all comes to a head that the real bargaining begins.&nb...

Too soon for a truce? Israel downplays push f...

| Alessandro XENOS | 2024

As Israeli jets continue to pound Lebanon, as top brass talk up the potential for a ground invasion, Hezbollah and its main backer Iran are more circumspect: they are still reeling from last week's exploding electronic devices and...

Netanyahu on all fronts: Can Israel keep up w...

| Rebecca GNIGNATI | 2024

In hindsight, Iran's first-ever direct missile attacks on Israel back in April seemed like a symbolic gesture, but it certainly got Binyamin Netanyahu's top brass's attention. The same top brass is at loggerheads with the prime mi...

What about the hostages? Netanyahu pushes bac...

| François PICARD | 2024

Netanyahu is doubling down on his decision to now prioritise the occupation of the Philadelphi corridor between Gaza and Egypt, while pushing back against growing pressure from allies. He has also called the UK’s decision to ...

Red carpet diplomacy: What's Macron's message...

| François PICARD

The last time that Macron hosted Xi, he invited then-German Chancellor Angela Merkel to join the talks alongside the European Commission president. This time, Ursula von der Leyen is in Paris, but not Olaf Scholz. We ask why and w...

Macron's Sinai signalling: Can France bolster...

| François PICARD

The visit is taking place the same day that Israel's Supreme Court rules whether the prime minister unfairly wants to dismiss the head of the Shin Bet intelligence service. The service just happened to have launched a probe into t...

Death of Yahya Sinwar: A turning point for th...

| François PICARD | 2024

Produced by Andrew Hilliar, Rebecca Gnignati and Ilayda Hapip. 

How serious is he? Trump's plan for Gaza

| François PICARD

How does one rebuild Gaza after destruction on a biblical scale? In the aftermath of past wars, Gulf states footed much of the bill. The money went to housing, but was also sometimes diverted by Hamas. We gauge regional react...

Chargement des enrichissements...